Ayn Rand: To push boundaries is indeed noble, but to what end? Is your work an expression of your highest values, or merely a challenge conquered?
Hank Gruberson: It's both. The sea floor is a canvas for progress. To conquer a challenge, to me, is an expression of my highest value—the value of man's mind over nature.
Ayn Rand: Nature, yes. But what of man? There are those who say your extractions are an affront to the natural world, and that you owe a debt to the society that grants you the freedom to create. How do you answer them?
Hank Gruberson: I owe nothing to society but to respect the rights of other individuals. If by my actions I enrich others, it is a byproduct, not a duty. My creations stand as a testament to human ingenuity; my debt is paid in the value I offer.
Ayn Rand: Indeed, you owe nothing to those who do not trade value for value. But tell me, Mr. Gruberson, is there not a point where the pursuit of one's own interests must acknowledge the fragility of the environment we all share?
Hank Gruberson: The environment's fragility is a technical problem that must be solved. We must use our ingenuity to overcome such challenges, not bow to them.
Ayn Rand: A technical problem, yes. But is there not a value to preserving the unspoiled state of nature, a value that goes beyond immediate utility?
Hank Gruberson: The unspoiled state of nature holds untold value because it serves man's life. But to hold it as an intrinsic value is to place it above human needs, which I cannot do. My mining serves life.
Ayn Rand: Mr. Gruberson, you are a man of conviction, shaping the world to your vision. Let us hope your vision is clear and your hands steady. Thank you for your candor.